Spasmodic Dysphonia Bulletin Board

positive experience with acupuncture
  Archive
Posted by: Brian Nels ®
05/10/2004, 21:22:03


I wanted to report a positive experience that I've had with acupunture. I've had about 8 sessions so far and have been pleased with the results.

(This email may be a bit long...sorry...I just want to report my experience as best I can)

Some background: I've had adductor SD for at least 15 years. I have had it at probably a moderate level -- at times, in busy noisy environments such as bustling restaurants, it can be very difficult for me to speak more than a few words, while other times, in more private locations, it doesn't seem to be a problem. However, it was a significant problem on the whole, and about eight months ago I had my first (and only) botox injection. The injection worked well, but I didn't like the 3 week period following it where I could hardly speak. And, as most people report, the results began to wear off after about 4 months. So, I wanted to find alternatives.

I was excited to find the following research online reported in the journal "Medical Acupuncture" in which "significant improvement" was found among patients who received treatment in particular acupunture points. (http://www.medicalacupuncture.org/aama_marf/journal/vol14_3/article4.html)

My experience parallels the study. I found a local acupuncture clinic and reviewed the article with them. My first 3-4 sessions were general sessions that didn't necessarily follow the protocol -- they may have had some effect, but I didn't notice it. I began to notice a difference after later sessions focusing on particular points in the ear (see the article for more info). And, I especially felt positive results when mild electical stimulation was applied to these points in the ear during the treatment (this is a common acupuncture procedure).

My general feeling after these sessions was that my voice felt deeper and more resonant -- I was aware of more vibration in my chest as I spoke. I practiced saying a few words that were especially hard for me -- I still felt some resistance on these words. (I was concerned that maybe it wasn't working. But in the days after, people commented during at a large dinner table that my voice sounded stronger). I also felt it easier in general to get words out.

I am still in the midst of acupuncture sessions. I don't want to raise false hopes, but I myself do feel optimistic. I was able to order food at a drive-through fast-food place, leaning out the window and projecting into the open space. I also was able to carry on conversations in noisy restaurants and exhibit halls. I would encourage people who are interested to review the article and consider acupunture as an alternative treatment.

Brian


Related link: acupuncture and SD study

| |   Current page

Replies to this message

Re: positive experience with acupuncture
Re: positive experience with acupuncture -- Brian Nels Top of thread Archive
Posted by: fancynancy ®
05/11/2004, 00:25:27


Wonderful news Brian! Glad you're having success with acupuncture.

I also tried acupuncture and chiropractic (deep neck adjustments) at the same time. At first it seemed to improve my voice. But after awhile, my speech actually got worse! I stopped the treatment and it took several months for my voice to get close to its pre-treatment stage (and it still hasn't completely recovered).

We're all different, and hopefully you'll have no problem. However, if you get to a point where your voice is getting worse, you may want to ease up on the acupuncture. Don't get me wrong--I believe acupuncture and chiropractic are beneficial, just in the proper amount for different people.

--fancynancy--
AB, central CA




| | Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: positive experience with acupuncture
Re: Re: positive experience with acupuncture -- fancynancy Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Brian Nels ®
05/11/2004, 19:02:22


Hi Nancy --

Thanks for your reply. Out of curiousity, how many sessions (or how often) did you have acupuncture before you started to feel it was becoming counter-productive?

(I realize as I write this, there may be tremendous variance depending on the points used, the person, etc. But I am curious about your experience).

thanks!

Brian




| | Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: positive experience with acupuncture
Re: Re: positive experience with acupuncture -- Brian Nels Top of thread Archive
Posted by: fancynancy ®
05/18/2004, 14:05:36


Hmm...I'd have to give it some thought, it's been awhile. Maybe 5 or 6 months? But the treatments weren't scheduled regularly.

The best advice I can give is to give it a try. And the minute you feel things are getting worse, stop immediately. Better yet, if you're at a plateau, quit while you're ahead. Just my opinion though.

--fn--




| | Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page
Re: positive experience with acupuncture
Re: Re: positive experience with acupuncture -- fancynancy Top of thread Archive
Posted by: Gary Lea ®
06/18/2004, 17:26:33


I tried the protocol about a year ago with no benefit. The acupuncturist, a Chinese native, was trained in Traditional Chinese Medicine in Beijing. I have had 2 other trials of acupuncture without success. The trial I had a year ago used the format defined in the article by Scheer and Lee. So,some SDers seem to benefit from acupuncture and probably most don't. Without trying, however, you don't know if it will help or not.

Gary Lea




| | Where am I? Original message Top of thread Current page