There is Hope


Posted by Darrin Holly ® , Aug 24,2001,14:12   Archive
I am a 34 year old engineer from Baltimore, MD who works for the local utility company. I am married and have 2 kids. Although on the surface I appeared to be a typical guy, there was something very different about me. I had spasmodic dysphonia.

I was first diagnosed with spasmodic dysphonia back in 1992, but my ordeal began long before then. As far back as I can remember, speech has always been a problem. As early as 5th and 6th grade, I remember on a consistent basis having to strain and push just to get my voice out. My speech difficulties caused me to be shy and quiet. I shun occasions where I would be called upon to speak in front of groups. I greatly limited my telephone talking. Instead, I poured my energy into academics and sports. As the years passed by, I learned how to camouflage my speech impediment. I avoided, like the plague, all situations in which my speech impediment would be displayed.

But after graduating from college with a degree in engineering and starting my professional career, I decided to look into my speech problem. I wanted to know, why was talking so much effort and difficult for me? At this point, I knew that I had a medical problem but I did not know that it was called spasmodic dysphonia. My search for an answer started with my primary physician who referred me to many specialists. My search ended at the National Institute of Health (NIH) where, after many tests, they diagnosed me with spasmodic dysphonia.

The original diagnosis was a relief in a way. It confirmed what I had already known - that something was wrong with my vocal chords. They did not work like everyone elses. But while the diagnosis provided some relief, it also produced plenty of anxiety. What was this thing called spasmodic dsyphonia? What type of treatments were available?

While at NIH, I was educated about botox injections and how they were used in the treatment of spasmodic dysphonia. After some careful consideration, I decided to pursue the botox injections. There were only a few places in the country that gave botox injections. I was fortunate to be located near several of them. I decided to get my botox injections at the Ear, Nose & Throat Associates at the Greater Baltimore Medical Center (GBMC) in Baltimore, MD. From 1993 to 2001, I received injections once a quarter (i.e. 4 times per year), alternating between the right and left side of my voice box every other visit. My physicians were Dr. Andrew Goldstone and Dr. Samuel Lumpkin.

The botox injections made a big difference. Before the botox injections, on a scale from 1 to 10, my voice operated on a 1. After starting taking botox injections, my voice improved all the way to a 7 during the peak periods. But as good as the botox injections were, there were some drawbacks such as: the initial breathy period; the continual need for repeated injections on a periodic basis; every dose of botox had a different potency which resulted in different end results; and after a while my vocal chords got use to the injections so that their effectiveness decreased with time.

In 2000, Dr. Andrew Goldstone, M.D. and Dr. Dario Kunar, M.D. began to tell me about a potential surgical alternative to botox injections. Both doctors, who teach on the staff at John Hopkins University, had heard about a surgical procedure called selective laryngeal adductor denervation - reinnervation that Dr. Berke was doing out at UCLA. After traveling to UCLA and seeing the procedure first hand, Dr. Goldstone and Dr. Kunar decided to offer the same surgical procedure on the East Coast at Greater Baltimore Medical Center (Baltimore, MD).

When the doctors explained to me the new procedure, I was more than willing to undertake the surgery. The potential benefits of the surgery were too great to turn down, so I volunteered to be their first patient. On July 12, 2001, Dr. Goldstone and Dr. Kunar performed the 5-hour procedure on me. Six weeks after the surgery, the results are remarkable. For the first time in more than 2 decades, I can talk effortlessly with no straining. The spasms and poor voice quality are gone. Thus far, I am thrilled
with the results.

But there are some downsides to the procedure. First and foremost, there is nothing fun about surgery. Secondly, for the first week after surgery, swallowing food and drinks often results in coughing because it goes down the wrong pipe. Thirdly, there is an extended breathy period after the surgery. Typically in the past with other patients who underwent the procedure on the West Coast, the breathy period lasted from 3 to 6 months. But to shorten the length of the breathy period, Dr. Goldstone and Dr. Kunar injected foam gel into my vocal chords after 6 weeks. This gel allowed for my vocal chords to close together when I talked. Therefore, my breathy period was reduced from the normal 3-6 months to 6 weeks.

So, what is the bottom line? There is hope for people suffering from spasmodic dysphonia. The new surgical procedure offers incredible benefits. On a scale of 1 to 10, my voice is now functioning at a 10. If given a chance to do it all over again, I would not hesitate to have the surgery. I'm just sorry that it took the new procedure so long to come along.




Recommend Current pageAuthor Profile
Replies to this message


Re: There is Hope

Re : There is Hope --- Darrin Holly
Posted by Lloyd Pearson(BC) ® , Aug 24,2001,15:57 Top of Thread Archive
Thank you Darrin for sharing your story and welcome to the SD BB. I found your story quite intriguing, as you are probably one of that quite "rare breed" who develop SD in their pre-teen years. You appear to have researched your voice problem in a mature and quietly un-assuming way. I also applaud you for continuing on with your life and your eventual academic successes despite the obstacles you were faced with. Congratulations on being the first to volunteer for de-re surgery with your physicians, who obviously believe in this surgery. It takes great courage to be the first.

Continued success in your recovery, and please keep the board informed of your progress as the healing continues.




Recommend Original Message Top of Thread Where am I? Current pageAuthor Profile
Re: There is Hope

Re : There is Hope --- Darrin Holly
Posted by Lylia Bennett ® , Aug 24,2001,21:07 Top of Thread Archive
Darrin, thank you for posting your story concerning SD. You have shown great courage in the face of great odds. This takes much strength of character. Not all of us are so well equipped.

Please keep us posted on your progress. My surgery with Dr. Berke and Dr. Blumin was 14 months ago. I, too, am very pleased with the surgery outcome. We also welcome you to the BB. It is so good to know that the surgery is being offered in other parts of the country. This should make the alternative easier for other patients to take advantage of. Lylia Bennett




Recommend Original Message Top of Thread Where am I? Current pageAuthor Profile