botox from ENT or neurologist?


Posted by Lorraine ® , Apr 10,2002,19:55   Archive
I currently get my botox injection from an ENT in Philly. I have found that there is a neurologist much closer to my home that gives the botox injection for SD. My concern is---is there a difference what kind of doctor gives the injection? Is one more apt to be better than the other? I would appreciate input as to what kind of Doctor gives you your injections. Thanks!



Recommend Current pageAuthor Profile
Replies to this message


Re: botox from ENT or neurologist?

Re : botox from ENT or neurologist? --- Lorraine
Posted by David Barton (NZ) ® , Apr 10,2002,20:20 Top of Thread Archive
A very common approach is for the Botox to be given by a team - the ENT with the detailed knowledge of the larynx anatomy so that very precise placement of the needle in the right position can take place, and a neurologist to interpret the signal from the EMG machine, and calibrate the right dose of Botox. This expertise isn't exclusive - some neurologist have considerable experience in doing the injections themselves, and some ENTs are well-versed in the "mixing and monitoring" procedure.

In my case I have injections from both types of medical specialist. Dr Paul Darveniza, St Vincent's Hospital, Sydney is a neurologist and Dr Bren Dorman, Auckland Hospital is an ENT specialist. Both knew/know exactly what they were doing. In 40 shots over an 11 year period I have had no misses. Getting the dose right and whether the shots should be unilateral or bilateral is another story.

David Barton (AD/SD, Auckland, NZ




Recommend Original Message Top of Thread Where am I? Current pageAuthor Profile
Re: botox from ENT or neurologist?

Re : Re: botox from ENT or neurologist? --- David Barton (NZ)
Posted by William Vanderlinde ® , Apr 11,2002,16:26 Top of Thread Archive
I have always had my BOTOX done by an ENT. I would agree with David that an ENT is more likely to be familiar with the anatomy of the larynx. But I have heard that there are some ENTs out there who are just dabbling in BOTOX treatments and don't get good results. On the other hand, neurologists typically specialize in giving BOTOX for other forms of dystonia such as torticollis, but some do inject for SD as well.

Probably the most important thing would be to find a physician who has lots of experience with the specific type of injection you need.

Bill Vanderlinde
AB/SD




Recommend Original Message Top of Thread Where am I? Current pageAuthor Profile
Re: botox from ENT or neurologist?

Re : Re: botox from ENT or neurologist? --- David Barton (NZ)
Posted by karen feeley ® , Apr 14,2002,21:50 Top of Thread Archive
I agree with William; it depends on your doctor's specialty. My neurologist gives botox shots for cervical distonia and writer's cramp, but referred me to an ENT for shots into the larynx. The neuro explained that he just didn't have experience giving shots into that area and would feel more comfortable if someone more experienced did it. I would suggest asking how familiar he is with giving such shots.

-Karen (AD/SD)




Recommend Original Message Top of Thread Where am I? Current pageAuthor Profile