Acupuncture?
  Archive
Posted by: Melissa K. Coughlin ®

01/13/2003, 15:05:18

Author Profile Mail author

Hi folks, I'm new to the board but have already received benefit from it by reading postings and responses from such intelligent, caring people.

I am an insurance agent specializing in group health benefits. My job requires lots of phone work and lots of in-person educational sessions. I get so aggravated when I come across sounding upset or tentative.

My SD is probably mild. It was officially diagnosed by an ENT MD, who suggested speech therapy. I've not bothered to follow up, because of a fellow SD's opinion (perhaps mis-guided) that they would teach me to speak breathy, which would be worse than my intermittent SD.

I've also not been thrilled with the idea of Botox because it only lasts a short time, has a period of down-time right after the injection, and the expense.

What experience has anyone had with acupuncture?







| Recommend | Alert   Previous | Next | Current page
Replies to this message


Re: Acupuncture?
Re: Acupuncture? -- Melissa K. Coughlin Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Lib Haywood ®

01/14/2003, 08:23:58

Author Profile Mail author

Over the years I tried three acupuncturists while continuing my BoTox injections. The one which helped the most was out of town. I drove two hours, had an hour session, had lunch and drove two hours back arriving in Charlotte, NC in the late afternoon traffic. She was great and helped a lot but by the time I had finished the day, I felt a lot of the benefit had been wiped out. Another lady in our support group goes to this same acupuncturist and she is well pleased. She lives close to her office. She has been going for several years and prior to starting with this lady, she was unable to perform her job of financial planner. Now with the acupunture and a small amount of BoTox she is back into her career and making presentations to large groups of people.

The second acupuncturist did not help at all. I went for three month, every week and I could not tell it helped. He was local and his method was completely different from the first one.

The third one was close by and she used electrical probes attached to the needles. This was entirely different from the first one and it did not help me, however, a lady in our support group has been going to her for about three years. She started every week, then every other week. Later she went to once a month and then every other month. She has not had Botox in three years and has a good voice.

It is worth a try. Everyone responds in different ways. It is important to find an acupuncturist who is familiar with the problem. The negative side is most insurance companies and Medicare does not cover it.







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture?
Re: Re: Acupuncture? -- Lib Haywood Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Melissa K. Coughlin ®

01/14/2003, 19:16:30

Author Profile Mail author

I guess the common denominator with the treatments is that there isn't one - everyone reacts differently, and it sounds like some people react differently to the same treatment at different times.

Any suggestions on finding experienced practitioners? I live in Northern California.

Thanks for your help!







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture? (and other contacts and referrals)
Re: Re: Acupuncture? -- Melissa K. Coughlin Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Lynne Martinez ®

01/14/2003, 20:10:18

Author Profile Mail author
Hi Melissa,

I will contact you on your private e-mail, or you could beat me to it and write me if you want. There are a number of resources in your local area.

I also live in Northern California. Would be glad to discuss this with you. In addition, the most active SD Support Group in Northern California meets just a few miles South of you (San Rafael/Terra Linda) this coming Sunday (1/19) at 3:00PM. Please attend if you can. It promises to be an outstanding meeting with excellent opportunities for information, contacts and support.

Congratulations on finding us, as you will get more solid, usable information here than just about any other place. There are many patients on this bulletin board who have done a decade or more of valuable personal research in order to manage their own individual case. Welcome aboard!

--Lynne (AD/SD - 13 years; NSDA Pacific Regional Coordinator)



--modified by Lynne Martinez at Tue, Jan 14, 2003, 21:59:54







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous |   | Current page
Re: Acupuncture?
Re: Acupuncture? -- Melissa K. Coughlin Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: fancynancy ®

01/16/2003, 01:58:30

Author Profile Mail author

Hi Melissa,

There have been several posts here about acupuncture. (Funny, I just got back from an acupuncture appointment yesterday). I've had a few procedures. The previous ones did little to help my voice, but these last couple of treatments are making positive changes! The only thing is, they wear off a few days later. I notice the improvement almost immediately. The doctor is trying a new technique.

It's worth trying, if you can get insurance. I have Kaiser Permanente, and they cover it.

--fancynancy--

AB SD, central CA







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture?
Re: Acupuncture? -- Melissa K. Coughlin Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Renee Urban ®

01/19/2003, 15:50:17

Author Profile Mail author

I tried acupuncture five times several years ago and it did me little good. But like everything with SD, everyone is different and if you're reluctant to try botox you might want to try it. I know that some people have had some luck with it...

Renee Urban ADSD/ Austin, TEXAS







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture?
Re: Acupuncture? -- Melissa K. Coughlin Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: gary lea ®

01/25/2003, 00:41:37

Author Profile Mail author

I've had four courses of acupuncture - two from a local Caucasian trained in Traditional Chinese medicine and two acupuncturists from Beijing. The last one followed a protocol defined in this BB last Fall. None of the four interventions had significant or sustained benefit.

Gary







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams
Re: Re: Acupuncture? -- gary lea Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Doris St. Clair ®

02/02/2003, 17:49:17

Author Profile Mail author

Hi Gary, I have considered acupuncture but what I am most interested in right now is mercury amalgams. I recently read about your plight with your SD and how you had your mercury amalgams removed. I have had AD/SD for about 8 years but back in the 60's I was living in California and had to have a back tooth capped. I believe it was suppose to be a temporary cap but nevertheless I kept it. In the 70's I started having bouts with a sore throat. I mentioned it to my GP and he suggested that I see a dentist. I asked my dentist if he thought my sore throat and pains in that one side of my throat could be coming from the tooth that was capped. He took an xray and said that the tooth looked fine and that it was probably a swollen saliva gland. So I dismissed it but continued to have a sore throat off and on as well as shooting pains at times. I never connected the mercury amalgams to my problem until I read your story. But started to recall how someone I met several years ago suggested that I have my mercury fillings replaced after hearing about my SD. I don't know if my dentist can remove the cap or not or if I need to see a hollistic dentist. Any suggestions from you or anyone else would be appreciated.

Doris St. Clair AD/SD VA







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams
Re: Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams -- Doris St. Clair Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Gary Lea ®

02/22/2003, 21:49:37

Author Profile Mail author

You might want to go to my story at www.buffalo-creek-press.com where I discuss my thoughts on mercury amalgams more fully. I am persuaded that there is a connection, ie, when I have DMSA or DMPA tratments to pull mercury from my body I still have pronounced sensations in my throat and face - MUCH less now than years ago when I had my first treatments. I have had quite a few now and believe that I have brought my mercury burden into the normal range. When I first had my amalgams out,however, I was way off the charts. My ND was astonished and laughingly asked if I'd ever worked around mercury (I hadn't). Just before I "tanked" vocally with SD my DDS wrongly put a gold crown over one of my mercury fillings. That's a no-no which he should have known about.






| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous | Next | Current page
Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams
Re: Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams -- Gary Lea Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Doris St. Clair ®

02/23/2003, 06:23:00

Author Profile Mail author

Hi Gary, I was impressed with your story at buffalo creek press.com and went to my dentist to have my amalgams removed. His answer was that there is more mercury in 1 shrimp than in all the amalgams in my mouth. My answer was "well, what if I had 1 shrimp in my mouth for 25 years"! He laughed and said that he understood my feeling and referred me to a specialist to have my amalgams removed, however, I have not set up an appointment. I started to think that it probably won't do any good but as I recall from your article you contribute having your amalgams removed to your voice improvement. So am not sure whether to do it or not. I also heard that if you want to have the amount of mercury that you have in your body that you can have a lock of hair tested. Don't know if this is true or not.

Doris St. Clair AD/SD VA







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous |   | Current page
Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams
Re: Re: Acupuncture/Mercury Amalgams -- Doris St. Clair Top of Thread Archive
Posted by: Steven Gibb ®

02/23/2003, 12:26:15

Author Profile Mail author

Doris,

Welcome to the board and before you go to have your fillings pulled out make sure you read Dr. Hal Huggins book..."It's all in your head" When you are ready to take on this task, write me and I can recommend a wonderful dentist who is very well versed in this subject not to mention extremely reasonable. On another note, most conventional dentist don't have a clue what they are taking about when it comes to mercury poising. I have well over 100 hours of research and have spoken to dentists all of the world.. I do believe that we all could live with mercury in our mouth and get by if our bodies were alkaline. But what has happened is our bodies became acidic instead of alkaline. When this happens it affects our saliva causing the mercury to dissolve in our mouth thus entering the blood stream. I can almost guarantee you that everyone on this board is acidic or they wouldn't be here as it a major element of sickness. Go buy some PH strips and check you saliva..you will be amazed at the results.

Much success on your journey.

Warmly,

Steven

Related link: http://www.geocities.com/rawfasting/rawfasting







| Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Message Top of Thread Previous |   | Current page